Sunset Island Ocean City: Your Guide to a Waterfront Paradise

Sunset Island, located on the bayside off 67th street in Ocean City, MD, is one of the Eastern Shore’s most sought-after communities — a planned, gated, waterfront neighborhood that blends serene bayside living with the vibrant energy of the beach.

Nestled along the Assawoman Bay and just two blocks from the Atlantic Ocean’s sandy shoreline, it’s a premier choice for retirees, families, and savvy investors looking for a little slice of paradise.

Here at the Fritschle Barker Group, we’re not just the top local realtors in Ocean City, MD — we live and breathe this beach town, and we’re passionate about helping others experience it.

Whether you’re searching for homes for sale in Ocean City, MD or just curious about Sunset Island, our goal is to keep you in the know.

Let’s dive right in!

All About Sunset Island

 

Developed in the early 2000s, Sunset Island is a thoughtfully planned resort community offering the best of coastal living. With its guarded, gated entrance and intimate layout, it feels like a peaceful escape — yet you’re still right in the heart of Ocean City. One of the things that makes Sunset Island stand out is it's amenities...

Community Amenities & Highlights Include:

·        Clubhouse & Pools: Indoor and outdoor pools, plus a kiddie pool for the little ones.

·        Fitness Center: Stay active without leaving the neighborhood.

·        Splash Pad & Interactive Fountains: Perfect for summer fun.

·        Private Beaches & Pier: Fish, crab, or simply relax with bayfront views.

·        Marina & Boat Slips: Over 100 slips available seasonally (April–October).

·        Market & Café: Your go-to for breakfast, coffee, and even a cold adult beverage.

·        Bayfront Bar & Grille: A seasonal tiki bar serving sunset views with your cocktails.

This mix of luxury amenities makes Sunset Island appealing to residents of all ages — from retirees looking for a slower pace to families and vacation homeowners who want both fun and relaxation.

Sunset Island Real Estate Market Overview

 

When it comes to Ocean City real estate, Sunset Island consistently commands premium values thanks to its location, amenities, and high demand.

Property Types & Price Ranges:

·        Condos: From the mid-$500s, offering 3 bedrooms, 2–3 baths, and select upgrades like fireplaces.

·        Townhomes: $700K+, 3–4 bedrooms, 2–4 baths, some with garages.

·        Single-Family Homes: $1M+, 3–5 bedrooms, 2–4 baths, with high-end finishes — some even with elevators.

Market Insights:

·        Well-priced homes and townhomes often go under contract in two weeks or less.

·        Buyers include retirees looking for low-maintenance living, families needing more space, and investors eyeing the strong vacation rental market (check with our friends at Central Reservations to explore rental potential).

Note: In recent years, certain condo buildings have faced substantial special assessments, some exceeding $100,000. While much of this seems to be behind the association, buyers should always know the history and future possibilities. Working with an experienced Ocean City Realtor can help you navigate negotiations and avoid surprises.

Things to Do Near Sunset Island

 

Location is everything — and Sunset Island puts you close to the best of Ocean City, MD.

·        Private Bayfront Beaches: Unwind in your own backyard.

·        Water Activities: Parasailing, jet skiing, fishing charters, and more.

·        Family Fun: Mini golf at Old Pro or local amusement parks.

·        Boating Adventures: Easy kayak and boat launches from the marina.

Best Places to Eat Near Sunset Island

 

The midtown location means you’re surrounded by fantastic dining options.

·        Skye Bar (66th St): Rooftop vibes, fresh seafood, and live music.

·        Longboard Café (67th St): Casual-upscale dining and a favorite among locals.

·        Fager’s Island (60th St): Award-winning seafood with famous sunset views.

·        Seacrets Hideaway (50th St): A new upscale bayfront spot from Ocean City’s most iconic entertainment venue.

If you’re a seafood lover, you can’t miss our local crab cakes. While we’re working on an Ocean City-specific list, check out our blog on the Top 5 Crab Cakes in West Ocean City.

Why We Recommend Sunset Island

Sunset Island offers a rare combination of luxury, privacy, and location. Its amenities, rental potential, and midtown address make it a smart choice for both living and investing in Ocean City real estate.

We’re often partial to the townhomes and single-family homes (due to recent condo assessments), but with the right approach and information, a Sunset Island condo can also be a fantastic buy.

Work with the Fritschle Barker Group

We know Sunset Island inside and out — and we’re ready to help you buy, sell, or invest with confidence.

·        Start your search with our saved Sunset Island listings

·        Check your home’s value with our free home valuation tool

Whether you’re here to retire, spend summers by the water, or rent out your property, Sunset Island delivers year after year.

Interested in a vacation rental in Ocean City or want to rent out your OC Condo? Contact our friends at Central Reservations!

Want to learn more about real estate in our area? Check out our YouTube Channel, Selling Ocean City!

Grant Fritschle
Email: grant@grantf.com
Cell: 410-430-5880
Office: 410-524-6400

Jon Barker
Email: jon@markf.com
Cell: 410-935-3810
Office: 410-524-6400

 

Qualifying Criteria: This guide was curated by a lifelong local realtor with The Fritschle Barker Group, drawing on deep knowledge of Glen Riddle and the MD/DE beach area from decades of professional expertise. Information was sourced from local expertise, plats.net, the community by laws from mdlandrec.net, and Bright MLS for sales data and other community information. Photos were obtained from Central Reservations, Longboard Café, and Canva to enhance the visual appeal of this guide.